Tuesday, April 28, 2015

Article review # 5

Williams, R. (2009, Nov. 29) Social Media: Does It Help or Hinder Productivity? Retrieved from



Summary

In this article, Williams analyzes whether or not the use of social media in the classroom helps or hinders student productivity.  Williams looks at both the younger generation and the older generation while at work or at school and how they use technology while at work or school.  He mentions that the older generation spends less time using technology at work than younger generations do.  Williams also writes about the positive and negative beliefs about social media in the work and school environments.
            Williams has found the negative image of social media users as those who lack interpersonal communication, are shallow and are considered “serial time wasters.”  He also mentions that schools are more likely to block various forms of social media as a way to increase productivity.  Williams also talks about a university study that shows that the more time spent on Facebook, the worse their study habits were and had lower grades as well. 
            Williams offers support for social media users as well.  He cites studies that have shown that students and younger workers today are better at multi-tasking.  He says that this is the case because this generation has made technology a part of their lives.  He then cites examples that show that with a minimal amount of technology, workers have shown a higher production level than those who use other “distractions” at work or school.  He says that the level of productivity increases as long as the user spends less than 20% of their time on the internet (for non-work related activities).  The argument is made to say that this is an opportunity for a mental break and has shown to increase productivity compared to those that either spend too much time on the internet or those that find other ways to distract themselves.




Reflection
Even before reading this article I had the opinion that social media can only hinder student achievement in the classroom.  However, I was shocked by the points that were made in the article.  I had only thought of how easily I can get distracted and thought that this was the same for my students.  I did not take into consideration the concept of today’s youth being so adept to multi-tasking.  Based on the ideas that were presented in this article, I have changed my opinion.  I think that using social media in the classroom can be a great benefit in the classroom, as long as it is still monitored by the teacher.  Relatively short mental breaks are good for the students and will hopefully increase their production as the end result.  I understand that students can multi-task, but it is still important for the students to be monitored to make sure that they are spending more time on task rather than “surfing” the net. 

No comments:

Post a Comment